Right after Abigail was potty trained, I did a conservative calculation and figured that we had spent at least $1800 on disposable diapers for her. Now, Abby is a camel and for a very long time leading up to potty training she used only about 5 diapers a day!
After some research online and asking my friends who had used cloth on their kids, I realized that if we used cloth diapers, we could spend about $500 total and get a child from birth through potty training. That's a huge savings!
I wasn't completely sold on cloth, though, not liking the idea of toting around dirty diapers and handling mounds of soiled and wet laundry items every few days. There are so many different types of cloth diapers, from prefolds with covers to fitted and one-size All-In-Ones and Pocket diapers. Prefolds didn't appeal to me and AIOs were bulky and hard to launder. Pocket diapers sounded the most simple and cost effective for our needs, but most didn't fit newborns well, so we figured that we would still use disposables to start.
We changed our minds almost as soon as Kayleigh was born. She went through 60 disposables in her first 3 days of life and continues to prove ultra-sensitive to a dirty diaper! So, I started to look more earnestly into cloth with the hope of protecting our bank accounts.
I bought a dozen newborn prefolds, snappies to fasten them, and two Thirsties Duo Wraps to cover the prefolds. Half of the prefolds were being used as burp clothes because I wasn't really committing to cloth diapering yet at this point. A couple of weeks later, though, I found a store that had a mix-and-match sale on pocket diapers, so I picked up 5 to try - 1 Happy Heinys, 2 bumGenius 3.0, 1 Sweet Pea, and 1 Rumparooz G2.
Since Kayleigh was born fairly large, at 8 lbs 7 ozs, I thought she might be able to start fitting into the pocket diapers, so they got washed and tested. After a few uses, I realized I really liked them! These pocket diapers, once stuffed with the inserts, were as easy to use as disposables.
One thing we didn't like right off the bat was having to remove the inserts before putting them in the diaper pail and having to throw away the wipes separately, rather than just rolling it up in the diaper and tossing the whole package away. So, this was a bit of inconvenience we hadn't anticipated.
A few weeks later, we learned that disposable diaper wipes go through the laundry very well, so we just toss them along with the dirty diaper into the pail and collect/toss them when moving things to the dryer. With the inserts, we have often forgotten to take them out and they come out of the wash just fine. The Rumparooz, though, have a "poop scoop" in the back which makes it harder for the insert to come out in the wash as easily as the others, so I leave the tag of the insert near the opening so that I have something to grab easily and pull out part-way.
All 5 diapers were good, but we were blown away by the Rumparooz (RaR). They have an inner gusset and "poop scoop" (see diagram below) which catch EVERYTHING. These diapers ride lower and we were really hesitant at first, but even with the worst messes which would have no doubt been a blow-out in a disposable, nothing gets out of the RaRs. They come with a contoured newborn insert which makes the diaper fit very trimly and more comfortably on a small baby. This insert later becomes a doubler for the regular insert when the baby gets older or for night-time wear. They are adorable with solid and patterned prints, and the quality is unbeatable. We have had stitches pulling out of our bumGenius and Happy Heinys and the PUL starting to wear away where the velcro snags the material. Nothing like that with the RaRs and they all still look as good as the first day we got them. They also have a more velvety micro-fleece lining on the inside and the laundry tabs are a lot less scratchy than the other velcro fastened diapers. Last, but not least, the RaRs were created by a local mom here in Golden, CO! The only negative I have on the RaRs is that because of the many folds in the gussets, sometimes very, very messy diapers lead to residue left in the gussets and I end up throwing them back in the wash. This has happened only once in the last 2 months, though. Oh, and also, these were the most expensive of the diapers we tried.
The next one I like is the Sweet Pea because it has openings in the front and back, making stuffing after laundering very, very easy and quick. Also, there's absolutely no need to remove the inserts after use because they always come out of one of the openings during the wash. They come in snaps only and I love the adjustability of their snaps the best. Sweet Peas are made in Canada and come with both a cotton insert and a hemp insert. The hemp is super absorbent, but also most difficult to dry!
The Happy Heinys (HH) and bumGenius (bG) were only ok for us. Both just didn't fit Kayleigh as well as the Rumparooz. They are really wide between the legs and the panel in the front for fastening seems to be uncomfortable for her. The flaps for the pocket openings are so large that they hang out and I find myself stuffing the edges inside after I fasten the diaper on Kayleigh. Color has bled from both of my bumGenius diapers and have permanently stained the velcro tabs pink. Both have had stitches come loose. However, even though they're only ok, they still work just fine and are kept in our repertoire. A lot of people LOVE their HH or bG diapers, but they just don't work the best for us. (We have completely stopped using prefolds as Kayleigh outgrew the newborn prefolds, even though the covers and snappies would still work for probably several more months.)
With all of the diapers, I have found that I like snaps better than velcro. Snaps are so easy to use, especially once you have an idea where you need to snap to get the best fit. The RaRs and Sweet Peas are perfectly stretchy to provide an excellent fit with the snaps. Snaps don't snag anything in the laundry and you won't ever find bits of poo in them as you may with the velcro tabs. However, Paul likes the velcro a lot better because he finds them easier to use - just like disposables. As a result, we currently have 9 RaRs (5 velcro, 4 snaps), 2 bGs (both velcro), 1 HH (velcro), and 1 Sweet Pea (they only come in snaps).
With only 13 diapers in our stash, we are able to use cloth during the day and disposables at night and sometimes when we are out of the house, but we wash diapers almost every day. This arrangement works well for us and we will add to our stash slowly.
The Colorado sun is so perfect for getting stains out of these diapers. If I see the slightest stain on any of the inserts or diapers after a wash, I place the item by a window and a few minutes later (up to an hour) it will be bright white before I toss it into the dryer with everything else. Everything comes out of the dryer looking great!
Overall, I'm happy to be using cloth - they're definitely not much more work than disposables. I only wish they were less bulky so I can fit more than 3 in my diaper bag when we are out and about.
We're definitely reducing the amount of disposables we go through, so we are sticking with these pocket diapers.
After some research online and asking my friends who had used cloth on their kids, I realized that if we used cloth diapers, we could spend about $500 total and get a child from birth through potty training. That's a huge savings!
I wasn't completely sold on cloth, though, not liking the idea of toting around dirty diapers and handling mounds of soiled and wet laundry items every few days. There are so many different types of cloth diapers, from prefolds with covers to fitted and one-size All-In-Ones and Pocket diapers. Prefolds didn't appeal to me and AIOs were bulky and hard to launder. Pocket diapers sounded the most simple and cost effective for our needs, but most didn't fit newborns well, so we figured that we would still use disposables to start.
We changed our minds almost as soon as Kayleigh was born. She went through 60 disposables in her first 3 days of life and continues to prove ultra-sensitive to a dirty diaper! So, I started to look more earnestly into cloth with the hope of protecting our bank accounts.
I bought a dozen newborn prefolds, snappies to fasten them, and two Thirsties Duo Wraps to cover the prefolds. Half of the prefolds were being used as burp clothes because I wasn't really committing to cloth diapering yet at this point. A couple of weeks later, though, I found a store that had a mix-and-match sale on pocket diapers, so I picked up 5 to try - 1 Happy Heinys, 2 bumGenius 3.0, 1 Sweet Pea, and 1 Rumparooz G2.
Since Kayleigh was born fairly large, at 8 lbs 7 ozs, I thought she might be able to start fitting into the pocket diapers, so they got washed and tested. After a few uses, I realized I really liked them! These pocket diapers, once stuffed with the inserts, were as easy to use as disposables.
One thing we didn't like right off the bat was having to remove the inserts before putting them in the diaper pail and having to throw away the wipes separately, rather than just rolling it up in the diaper and tossing the whole package away. So, this was a bit of inconvenience we hadn't anticipated.
A few weeks later, we learned that disposable diaper wipes go through the laundry very well, so we just toss them along with the dirty diaper into the pail and collect/toss them when moving things to the dryer. With the inserts, we have often forgotten to take them out and they come out of the wash just fine. The Rumparooz, though, have a "poop scoop" in the back which makes it harder for the insert to come out in the wash as easily as the others, so I leave the tag of the insert near the opening so that I have something to grab easily and pull out part-way.
All 5 diapers were good, but we were blown away by the Rumparooz (RaR). They have an inner gusset and "poop scoop" (see diagram below) which catch EVERYTHING. These diapers ride lower and we were really hesitant at first, but even with the worst messes which would have no doubt been a blow-out in a disposable, nothing gets out of the RaRs. They come with a contoured newborn insert which makes the diaper fit very trimly and more comfortably on a small baby. This insert later becomes a doubler for the regular insert when the baby gets older or for night-time wear. They are adorable with solid and patterned prints, and the quality is unbeatable. We have had stitches pulling out of our bumGenius and Happy Heinys and the PUL starting to wear away where the velcro snags the material. Nothing like that with the RaRs and they all still look as good as the first day we got them. They also have a more velvety micro-fleece lining on the inside and the laundry tabs are a lot less scratchy than the other velcro fastened diapers. Last, but not least, the RaRs were created by a local mom here in Golden, CO! The only negative I have on the RaRs is that because of the many folds in the gussets, sometimes very, very messy diapers lead to residue left in the gussets and I end up throwing them back in the wash. This has happened only once in the last 2 months, though. Oh, and also, these were the most expensive of the diapers we tried.
The next one I like is the Sweet Pea because it has openings in the front and back, making stuffing after laundering very, very easy and quick. Also, there's absolutely no need to remove the inserts after use because they always come out of one of the openings during the wash. They come in snaps only and I love the adjustability of their snaps the best. Sweet Peas are made in Canada and come with both a cotton insert and a hemp insert. The hemp is super absorbent, but also most difficult to dry!
The Happy Heinys (HH) and bumGenius (bG) were only ok for us. Both just didn't fit Kayleigh as well as the Rumparooz. They are really wide between the legs and the panel in the front for fastening seems to be uncomfortable for her. The flaps for the pocket openings are so large that they hang out and I find myself stuffing the edges inside after I fasten the diaper on Kayleigh. Color has bled from both of my bumGenius diapers and have permanently stained the velcro tabs pink. Both have had stitches come loose. However, even though they're only ok, they still work just fine and are kept in our repertoire. A lot of people LOVE their HH or bG diapers, but they just don't work the best for us. (We have completely stopped using prefolds as Kayleigh outgrew the newborn prefolds, even though the covers and snappies would still work for probably several more months.)
With all of the diapers, I have found that I like snaps better than velcro. Snaps are so easy to use, especially once you have an idea where you need to snap to get the best fit. The RaRs and Sweet Peas are perfectly stretchy to provide an excellent fit with the snaps. Snaps don't snag anything in the laundry and you won't ever find bits of poo in them as you may with the velcro tabs. However, Paul likes the velcro a lot better because he finds them easier to use - just like disposables. As a result, we currently have 9 RaRs (5 velcro, 4 snaps), 2 bGs (both velcro), 1 HH (velcro), and 1 Sweet Pea (they only come in snaps).
With only 13 diapers in our stash, we are able to use cloth during the day and disposables at night and sometimes when we are out of the house, but we wash diapers almost every day. This arrangement works well for us and we will add to our stash slowly.
The Colorado sun is so perfect for getting stains out of these diapers. If I see the slightest stain on any of the inserts or diapers after a wash, I place the item by a window and a few minutes later (up to an hour) it will be bright white before I toss it into the dryer with everything else. Everything comes out of the dryer looking great!
Overall, I'm happy to be using cloth - they're definitely not much more work than disposables. I only wish they were less bulky so I can fit more than 3 in my diaper bag when we are out and about.
We're definitely reducing the amount of disposables we go through, so we are sticking with these pocket diapers.
Wednesday, June 02, 2010 |
Category: |
1 comments
Comments (1)
Yeay! I'm glad you found a diaper that works well for you! We've loved our cloth diapers for Wombat and will definitely use them again with Wallaby. Here are some other benefits that come later that are rarely advertised:
1. When they start walking, falling on a cloth-diaper padded bottom is a lot less painful. :)
2. When potty training, cloth diapers are more moist then paper ones, and so make potty more appealing. (Not that Abby took a long time with that...)
3. Some cloth diapers are cute enough to wear sans pants! Especially for a girl, under a dress.
Enjoy! Welcome to the world of cushy bottoms! :)